The Secondary Market for Fine Art Photography: 2024 Performance Analysis

I. Executive Summary: 2024 Secondary Photography Market Highlights

The secondary market for fine art photography demonstrated notable resilience in 2024, navigating a challenging global art market environment characterized by economic headwinds and geopolitical uncertainty.1 While not immune to the broader market contraction, photography sales experienced a significantly more moderate decline compared to other fine art sectors. Total photography auction sales at the three major international houses—Sotheby's, Christie's, and Phillips—reached $59.0 million in 2024, representing a decrease of 5.6% from the previous year.1 This performance stands in stark contrast to the overall fine art auction market (encompassing Old Masters, Impressionist, Modern, Post-War, and Contemporary art), which saw a much steeper decline of 27% year-on-year at the same houses.1

This relative stability occurred amidst a market correction that particularly impacted high-value segments across the art world.7 Key trends observed in the 2024 photography market included the continued, albeit potentially stabilizing, importance of online sales channels 2, a significant surge in private sales conducted by auction houses 11, and pronounced activity within the lower price tiers, specifically for works valued under $5,000.1 Auction results were mixed, often revealing weakness at the highest estimate levels within dedicated photography sales, yet punctuated by strong prices for select works and numerous instances of lots significantly exceeding expectations.13 Certain artists, notably Richard Prince, dominated the top end of the market, with Christie's emerging as the leading venue for the year's most valuable photography consignments.18 Overall, 2024 painted a picture of a discerning, value-conscious photography market adapting to broader economic pressures, finding strength in accessibility and diversification.

II. Overall Market Performance: Resilience Amidst Broader Art Market Contraction

Headline Figures and Comparative Analysis

The secondary photography market's performance in 2024 is best understood within the context of the wider art market's significant contraction. Aggregate photography auction sales at Sotheby's, Christie's, and Phillips totaled $59.0 million for the year.1 While this figure marks a 5.6% decrease compared to 2023 totals, it represents a considerably softer landing than that experienced by the broader fine art auction market. Data indicates that combined sales across Old Masters, Impressionist, Modern, Post-War, and Contemporary art categories at these same auction houses plummeted by 27% year-on-year.1 This juxtaposition clearly underscores the photography segment's relative resilience during a period of widespread market adjustment.

Table 1: Overall Photography Auction Sales (Sotheby's, Christie's, Phillips) 2024 vs. 2023

Macroeconomic Context and Market Impact

The global art market in 2024 operated under considerable pressure from external factors. Persistent geopolitical tensions, including ongoing wars and numerous significant elections worldwide, contributed to a climate of uncertainty.2 Economic volatility, marked by stubbornly high inflation in some regions and higher-for-longer interest rates, further weighed on buyer and seller sentiment.2 These conditions created what many analysts termed a "buyer's market," characterized by increased caution and price sensitivity.7

This challenging environment had a particularly pronounced effect on the highest echelons of the art market. Sales for works priced between $10 million and $100 million dropped by a staggering 45.5% in 2024 across the major houses, a rate nearly four times that of works priced under $1 million (-12.5%).7 The scarcity of "trophy" consignments was evident; only one nine-figure lot came to auction in 2024, compared to six in 2022.11 This contraction at the top end significantly dragged down overall market value totals.7

The photography market's relative insulation from this top-end volatility likely contributed to its more stable performance. With the highest-priced photograph selling for approximately $2.6 million in 2024 18, the segment operates well below the $10 million+ threshold that experienced the most severe downturn. Photography's generally lower average price points and the nature of editioned works, which can offer more predictable pricing and availability compared to unique paintings or sculptures, may have shielded it from the acute supply constraints and buyer hesitancy affecting the ultra-high-value market.

Transaction Volume vs. Value

A notable trend across the broader art market in 2024 was a divergence between sales value and transaction volume. While overall sales values declined significantly (e.g., -12% globally according to one report 2), the actual number of transactions often held steady or even increased.2 For instance, one analysis reported a 3% rise in global transaction volume to 40.5 million 2, while another noted a record 804,350 lots sold at auction globally (+5% YoY).21 This indicates that market activity remained robust, particularly at lower price levels, even as the total value contracted due to the slowdown at the top. The photography market, with its documented growth in the sub-$5,000 segment 1, aligns with and likely benefited from this shift in activity towards more accessible price points.

The photography market's comparatively steady performance in 2024, viewed against the backdrop of significant overall market decline and extreme volatility at the top end, could bolster its standing as a relatively stable and accessible collecting field. In an environment marked by economic uncertainty and a flight from riskier assets, photography's characteristics might attract collectors seeking entry points, diversification, or perceived value, especially compared to more volatile segments like ultra-contemporary art, which saw significant price corrections.10 The increased transaction volume across the market, despite falling total values, suggests a broadening base of activity at lower price points – a domain where photography is strongly represented and increasingly accessible through online platforms.

III. Auction House Analysis: Christie's, Sotheby's, and Phillips Photography Sales in 2024

Overall House Performance Context

The major auction houses navigated the challenging 2024 market with varying degrees of success. Christie's reported a relatively modest overall decline of 6% in total sales (art and luxury) to $5.7 billion, aided significantly by a booming private sales division, which amassed $1.5 billion, a 41% increase year-on-year, offsetting a 16% drop in public auction turnover.11 Sotheby's experienced a steeper decline of 31.2% in total sales in the first half of the year.26 Phillips weathered the storm comparatively well, reporting the smallest sales drop among the top three houses in the first half, down 12.7% to $252 million.26 Christie's strength in private sales highlights a broader market trend where sellers sought discretion and certainty away from the public auction spotlight amidst volatility.2

Performance in Dedicated and Mixed Photography Sales

Analysis of specific photography sales reveals inconsistent performance across the houses in 2024:

• Christie's: The house's dedicated photography auctions showed mixed results. An April online sale totaled $2.77 million, landing just above its aggregate low estimate. While featuring several positive surprises – notably Irving Penn's 'The Hand of Miles Davis' fetching $302,400 against a $100,000-150,000 estimate, and strong results for works by Josef Koudelka, Ralph Eugene Meatyard, Robert Mapplethorpe, Peter Hujar, Ana Mendieta, and Sebastião Salgado – the sale suffered from weakness in its top price tier, with high-profile lots by William Eggleston, Edward Weston, and Peter Beard failing to sell. The buy-in rate hovered near 28%.13 Photography offered within the October Post-War to Present sale fared worse, totaling just over $1.2 million, well below the low estimate for the photographic lots. The buy-in rate for photography in this sale was high at nearly 35%, with top lots by Barbara Kruger failing to sell and Thomas Struth selling within estimates. Only one photograph, by Massimo Vitali, registered as a positive surprise.14 A December First Open online sale saw photography total approximately $530,000, again below the aggregate low estimate. While the buy-in rate was lower (18%), top lots by Hiroshi Sugimoto and Florian Maier-Aichen underperformed.27 Despite these struggles in dedicated/mixed sales, Christie's demonstrated strength in placing high-value photographs, securing eight of the top ten photography lots sold globally in 2024, likely within major 20th/21st Century evening sales.18

• Sotheby's: Sotheby's photography sales also presented challenges. An October online sale, described as "generally uneventful," totaled $1.96 million, falling short of its aggregate low estimate. Weakness was noted in the middle and upper price tiers, contributing to a buy-in rate exceeding 30%. While a Peter Hujar portrait of David Wojnarowicz achieved the top price ($228,000 vs. $50,000-70,000 estimate), and works by Robert Frank, Larry Sultan, Bill Owens, Robert Capa, Henri Cartier-Bresson, Peter Beard, and Bert Stern provided positive surprises, these were insufficient to lift the overall result.15 Similarly, photography included in a September Contemporary Curated sale underperformed, realizing $335,000 against a low estimate of $390,000. The buy-in rate was 25%, and there were no positive surprises, although the top lot, a Gerhard Richter work, sold within its estimate range.28 Listings from these sales included works by prominent names like Robert Adams, Bernd and Hilla Becher, Hiroshi Sugimoto, Richard Avedon, Helmut Newton, and Robert Mapplethorpe.29

• Phillips: Phillips presented a more consistent performance in its dedicated photography auctions. An April sale achieved $3.0 million, exceeding its aggregate low estimate. The buy-in rate was around 26%, and the top lot, a Richard Avedon portrait of Francis Bacon, sold comfortably within its range ($114,300). The sale was buoyed by numerous positive surprises from artists including Cindy Sherman, Martin Parr, Hiroshi Sugimoto, Chris McCaw, Michael Dweck, Robert Longo, William Heick, Harry Callahan, Aaron Siskind, Lisette Model, Ansel Adams, Bert Stern, and William Wegman.17 The momentum continued in October, with a sale totaling $3.55 million, again landing just above the low estimate despite a buy-in rate near 30%. The top lot, an Alfred Stieglitz winter scene, sold for $304,800 (within estimate). Positive surprises included works by Burt Glinn, Flip Schulke, Peter Hujar, Francesca Woodman, Bruce Davidson, Nan Goldin, and Slim Aarons.16 Phillips' sales featured works by artists such as Andy Warhol, Helena Almeida, Ana Mendieta, Robert Mapplethorpe, Nan Goldin, David Hockney, Sally Mann, and Hiroshi Sugimoto.32

The variable performance, particularly the struggles with higher-priced lots in dedicated photography sales at Christie's and Sotheby's, suggests potential difficulties in sourcing or accurately pricing top-tier photographic works specifically for these specialized auctions. Phillips' relative consistency might indicate a stronger foothold or more effective strategy within this specific sale format during 2024. Conversely, Christie's success in achieving the year's highest prices, likely through integration into major contemporary evening sales 18, points towards the effectiveness of positioning exceptional photographs within a broader fine art context to attract top collectors.

Furthermore, the frequent occurrence of high buy-in rates (often 25-35%) across houses 13, particularly impacting mid-range and high-estimate lots, signals significant price sensitivity among buyers. Yet, the simultaneous presence of numerous "positive surprises" – lots selling for more than double their high estimates 13 – indicates focused, competitive bidding for specific, desirable works. This dichotomy suggests a highly selective market where buyers were wary of perceived overpricing but willing to compete fiercely for works deemed exceptional, fresh, or potentially underestimated, pointing to both valuation challenges and pockets of strong demand.

Christie's apparent dominance in securing the year's most valuable photography lots 18, coupled with its significant growth in private sales 11, may reflect a strategic advantage. The auction house might be leveraging its robust private sales channels to offer discretion sought by sellers in a cautious market, or successfully curating key photographs into major evening sales that command broader attention. This potentially more flexible approach to handling top-tier photography consignments aligns with the broader market shift towards private dealing and strategic placement observed in 2024.2

IV. Key Auction Results and Standout Sales

Examining specific auction results from 2024 provides concrete evidence of market activity, price levels, and collector interest in particular artists and works.

Top Performing Lots of 2024

The highest end of the secondary photography market in 2024 was dominated by established names, with Christie's securing the majority of the top results. Richard Prince's 'Untitled (Cowboy)' works were particularly prominent, occupying the top three spots. The year's highest price was achieved for his 1997 'Untitled (Cowboy)', which sold for £2,097,000 (approximately $2.6 million) at Christie's London in October.18 Another Prince 'Untitled (Cowboy)' from 1999 sold for $1.865 million at Christie's New York in November, followed by his 'Silhouette Cowboy' (1998-1999) realizing $1.744 million in a Christie's day sale.18

Other notable seven-figure results included a new world auction record for William Eggleston, whose 'Untitled' (c1971-1974/2012) fetched $1.441 million at Christie's in November. Diane Arbus's iconic 'Identical twins, (Cathleen and Colleen), Roselle, New Jersey, 1966' (printed 1967-1969) sold for $1.197 million at Christie's in May. A vintage 1927 print of Edward Weston's 'Shell (Nautilus)' achieved $1.071 million, also at Christie's in May.18

Rounding out the top ten were Richard Avedon's 'Marilyn Monroe, Actress, New York City, 1957' ($882,000, Christie's), Cindy Sherman's 'Untitled #94' (1981) ($806,400, Christie's), Andreas Gursky's 'New York, Mercantile Exchange' (2000) (£609,600 / ~$755,904, Phillips), and Ansel Adams's 'Aspens, Northern New Mexico (Vertical)' (1958/1970s) (720,000,Sotheby′s).[18]∗∗Table2:Top10PhotographyLotsSoldatAuctionin2024∗∗∣Rank∣Artist∣Title∣Date∣Estimate(£/) | Price Realized ($) | Auction House | Sale / Date |

| :--- | :---------------- | :----------------------------------------------------------------- | :---------- | :------------------ | :----------------- | :-------------- | :-------------------------- |

| 1 | Richard Prince | Untitled (Cowboy) | 1997 | £1.2M-1.8M | $2,600,280 | Christie's | London Evening / Oct 9 |

| 2 | Richard Prince | Untitled (Cowboy) | 1999 | $1.0M-1.5M | $1,865,000 | Christie's | NY 21st C Evening / Nov 21 |

| 3 | Richard Prince | Silhouette Cowboy | 1998-1999 | $600k-800k | $1,744,000 | Christie's | NY PWC Day / Nov 22 |

| 4 | William Eggleston | Untitled | c1971-74/12 | $700k-900k | $1,441,500 | Christie's | NY 21st C Evening / Nov 21 |

| 5 | Diane Arbus | Identical twins, (Cathleen and Colleen), Roselle, New Jersey, 1966 | 1967-1969 | $800k-1.2M | $1,197,000 | Christie's | NY 21st C Evening / May 14 |

| 6 | Edward Weston | Shell (Nautilus) | 1927 | $800k-1.2M | $1,071,000 | Christie's | NY 20th C Evening / May 16 |

| 7 | Richard Avedon | Marilyn Monroe, Actress, New York City, 1957 | 1957 | $600k-800k | $882,000 | Christie's | NY 21st C Evening / May 14 |

| 8 | Cindy Sherman | Untitled #94 | 1981 | $300k-500k | $806,400 | Christie's | NY PWC Day / Nov 22 |

| 9 | Andreas Gursky | New York, Mercantile Exchange | 2000 | £250k-350k | $755,904 | Phillips | London Evening / Oct 10 |

| 10 | Ansel Adams | Aspens, Northern New Mexico (Vertical) | 1958/1970s | $150k-250k | $720,000 | Sotheby's | Meredith Collection / Oct 16 |

| Source: 18 | | | | | | | |

Additional Highlights and Underperformers

Beyond the absolute top lots, several other works achieved strong prices, often significantly exceeding pre-sale expectations. Peter Hujar emerged as a notable performer in 2024, with his 'Self-Portrait (with string around his neck)' (1980) selling for $252,000 against a $50,000-70,000 estimate at Christie's 13, his 'David Wojnarowicz Reclining (II)' (1981) fetching $228,000 versus a $50,000-70,000 estimate at Sotheby's 15, and his 'David Wojnarowicz (Village Voice...)' (1983) realizing $139,700 against a $30,000-50,000 estimate at Phillips.16 Irving Penn's 'The Hand of Miles Davis' (1986) more than doubled its high estimate to sell for $302,400 at Christie's.13 Alfred Stieglitz's 'From the Back Window–291–Snow Covered Tree, Back-Yard' (1915) sold solidly within estimate for $304,800 at Phillips.16 Harry Callahan's 'Eleanor/Silhouette (Chicago)' (1948) soared past its $20,000-30,000 estimate to achieve $76,200 at Phillips.17

However, these successes were counterbalanced by disappointments, particularly for high-estimate lots within dedicated photography sales. Works by major figures like William Eggleston, Edward Weston, and Peter Beard failed to find buyers in Christie's April sale.13 A significant Barbara Kruger print went unsold in Christie's October Post-War sale 14, and a high-estimate Hiroshi Sugimoto piece was bought-in during Christie's December online sale.27 A Robert Frank photograph estimated at $200,000-300,000 sold below its low estimate for $180,000 at Sotheby's October sale.15 This pattern reinforces the observation of weakness and price sensitivity at the upper end of specialized photography auctions in 2024.

Price Realization Relative to Estimates

The relationship between hammer prices and pre-sale estimates varied across sales. While many auctions reported a high percentage of lots selling within or above their estimate ranges (e.g., 89% at Christie's April sale 13, 87% at Phillips October sale 16, 93% at Phillips April sale 17), this metric can sometimes mask underlying weakness if estimates themselves are conservative or if a few strong results balance out underperformers. Some sales saw a significant number of lots selling below their low estimates (e.g., 13% at Phillips October sale 31, 32% across marquee May auctions generally 25, and potentially higher proportions in sales like Christie's December online auction where only 53% sold in or above range 27). This variability underscores the market's ongoing recalibration, where buyers rigorously assessed value and resisted estimates they deemed too high.4

The concentration of top 2024 prices around established, predominantly male, blue-chip artists confirms their continued market leadership.18 However, the peak price of $2.6 million marks a significant cooling from the $12.4 million Man Ray record set in 2022 and falls short of top prices achieved in several intervening years.18 This moderation at the pinnacle of the photography market mirrors the broader art market's caution and reduced appetite for risk at the highest value levels in 2024.

Concurrently, the consistent outperformance of estimates by artists like Peter Hujar 13 suggests a dynamic counter-narrative. This strong demand points towards active collector and potentially institutional interest extending beyond the most canonical figures, perhaps fueled by recent exhibitions, publications, or a critical reassessment leading to competitive bidding that outpaced expectations. This contrasts sharply with the difficulties faced by some high-estimate lots from more traditionally recognized masters.13

Taken together, the 2024 auction results – characterized by a lower ceiling at the top, selective high prices, notable underperformances, high buy-in rates juxtaposed with strong positive surprises – depict a highly discerning secondary market. Collectors demonstrated a clear willingness to pay premiums for works perceived as exceptional, historically significant, or newly desirable, yet pushed back against estimates viewed as inflated. This reflects the broader "buyer's market" dynamic 7 prevalent across the art world in 2024, necessitating ongoing price adjustments and careful consignment strategies.4

V. Dominant Trends Shaping the 2024 Photography Market

Several key trends influenced the dynamics of the secondary photography market throughout 2024, reflecting broader shifts in the art world and the specific characteristics of the medium.

Online and Private Sales Dynamics

The migration towards digital channels and private transactions continued to shape the market landscape.

• Persistence of Online Channels: Online sales maintained a significant presence, accounting for 18% of the total global art market value in 2024, consistent with 2023 and substantially higher than pre-pandemic levels (13% in 2019).2 While the total value of online art sales saw a dip (estimated between $10.5 billion and $11.8 billion globally, down from 2023) 2, this was largely in line with the overall market decline. Crucially, the volume of online transactions continued to grow; one report indicated over 29,000 works sold online in 2024 (+6.6% YoY).9 The average price of art sold online decreased, suggesting a higher volume of lower-priced works being transacted digitally.9 Online platforms remain a critical entry point for new buyers 2, with data suggesting a high preference among collectors for online purchasing options.34 For photography, with its often more accessible price points and editioned nature, online channels provide a vital marketplace.

• Surge in Private Sales: Counterbalancing the decline in public auction turnover was a marked increase in private sales facilitated by auction houses. Christie's reported a 41% year-on-year increase in private sales, reaching $1.5 billion.11 This trend was observed across the market 2 and is largely attributed to sellers seeking discretion, guaranteed prices, or avoidance of public exposure during a period of market uncertainty and potential volatility.11 While specific data for private photography sales is not typically disclosed, the overall trend suggests that significant transactions for high-value photographs may also have shifted towards private channels in 2024.

Shifting Collector Preferences

Collector tastes and priorities showed evolving patterns in 2024.

• Subject Matter and Style: Expert commentary highlighted strong demand within photography for portraiture, particularly images featuring well-known cultural figures or celebrities. Color photography reportedly garnered more interest than black-and-white, and nature or landscape photography remained popular, possibly reflecting broader environmental concerns or aesthetic preferences for the home.35 Figurative art, often verging on melancholy or telling intimate stories, was noted as a broader trend at art fairs.36

• Artist Focus: Demand remained robust for established blue-chip photographers like Richard Prince, William Eggleston, Edward Weston, Ansel Adams, Hiroshi Sugimoto, Gordon Parks, and Robert Mapplethorpe, as evidenced by top auction results and platform interest.18 Simultaneously, a significant portion of collector spending, particularly among High-Net-Worth Individuals (HNWIs), was directed towards new and emerging artists. One survey found HNWIs allocated 52% of their expenditure to this segment in 2023-2024.37 This trend is often driven by younger collectors (Gen Z and Millennials) entering the market.37 Platforms like Artsy identified numerous emerging photographers gaining traction, indicating active discovery.35 The increased visibility of indigenous artists was also noted as a significant trend across the art world.36

• Demographics and Diversity: There was a discernible increase in the representation and collection of works by women artists. The share of works by female artists in surveyed HNWI collections reached a seven-year high of 44%.37 Online platforms also reported growth in inquiries for women artists, reaching 26% overall and 37% for ultra-contemporary women artists on Artsy.34 Furthermore, analysis pointed to growing geographical diversity, with emerging photographic talent gaining recognition from regions like Africa and Latin America.35

Economic and Geopolitical Influences

The broader economic and political climate cast a long shadow over the market.

• Market Caution and Recalibration: The combination of high interest rates, inflation concerns, geopolitical instability (wars in Ukraine and Gaza, tensions elsewhere), and political uncertainty (particularly the US election cycle) fostered a cautious approach among buyers and sellers.2 This translated into reduced impulse buying 37, more thorough pre-purchase research, and heightened price sensitivity, especially for high-value items where financing costs or alternative investment returns became more pertinent factors.42 The market underwent a necessary recalibration after the rapid growth of the post-pandemic years.5

• Business Costs: Rising operational costs were cited as a key challenge for art businesses, particularly galleries, in 2023 and likely continuing into 2024.20 This pressure could influence pricing strategies, participation in art fairs, and overall profitability, potentially impacting the primary market supply feeding the secondary market.

• Regional Economic Variations: The global art market slowdown was not uniform. China experienced a particularly sharp contraction, losing its second-place ranking to the UK, attributed to economic slowdown and a property sector crisis.3 The US maintained its leading position despite a significant decline.3 European markets also saw declines, though France remained relatively stable.3 These regional economic disparities affect the geographic distribution of buying power. Additionally, trade policies, such as potential US tariffs on imported photographs, remain a background concern for international dealers.19

The convergence of strong private sales 11 and robust activity in the lower-end public market (sub-$5k photography) 1, contrasted with the struggles of high-value public auctions 7, points to a significant market bifurcation in 2024. This split appears driven by risk aversion and a search for value. Sellers of top lots increasingly opted for the discretion and certainty of private negotiation, while public auction activity gravitated towards more accessible price points, readily facilitated by online platforms. Photography, with its strong representation across these lower price tiers, was well-positioned to capture this shifted activity.

The concurrent demand for both established historical masters 18 and emerging contemporary talents 35 signals a healthy diversity within the photography collector base. While current peak auction values are still commanded by historical figures, the substantial allocation of funds towards emerging artists by HNWIs 37, especially younger generations 38, suggests a potential long-term evolution in market focus. This influx of new energy and taste may reshape the secondary market landscape in the coming years.

Furthermore, the documented rise in demand for works by women photographers 34 and artists from diverse global backgrounds 35 is more than a matter of equity; it represents a tangible market dynamic. This broadening of the recognized canon creates new collecting opportunities, potentially fuels growth in previously undervalued segments, and injects dynamism into the market, contributing to its overall vitality even amidst broader contraction.

VI. Segment Focus: Performance Across Photography Categories

Analyzing performance within specific segments of the photography market provides a more granular understanding of the dynamics observed in 2024.

Photography's Position in the Broader Art Market

Before delving into internal segments, it is crucial to contextualize photography's overall market share. Data indicates that photography occupies a relatively niche position in terms of overall fine art market value. Dealer sales data for 2024 shows photography holding a stable 3% share of sales value, consistent with previous years.19 This is dwarfed by painting, which dominates the market at approximately 71% of value, followed by works on paper (around 14%) and sculpture (around 9%).22 This highlights that while photography demonstrated resilience and growing transaction volume, its contribution to the total dollar value of the global art market remains modest compared to traditional media.

Table 3: Fine Art Market Segment Share (Dealer Sales Value, 2024)

Vintage vs. Contemporary Photography

Expert commentary suggests a potential shift in emphasis within the photography market in 2024. There was an observation that vintage prints by historical masters (such as Edward Weston and Richard Avedon) gained ground, perhaps eclipsing the dominance that photo-based contemporary artworks held a decade prior.45 This view positions the photography market as operating in parallel with both the contemporary art sphere and the market for historical works like Old Masters.45 The strong seven-figure results achieved in 2024 for vintage prints by Weston, Arbus, Adams, and Stieglitz lend credence to this perspective.16 However, contemporary photographers like Richard Prince, Andreas Gursky, and Cindy Sherman also commanded top prices 18, indicating continued strength for key contemporary figures. The market appears to support both historical significance and contemporary relevance, catering to different collector interests.

Performance of Notable Artists and Genres

As detailed in Section IV, certain artists consistently appeared in auction highlights. Richard Prince was dominant at the very top end.18 William Eggleston set a new record.18 Established masters like Diane Arbus, Edward Weston, Ansel Adams, and Alfred Stieglitz achieved strong prices for prime vintage works.16 Contemporary figures like Cindy Sherman and Andreas Gursky remained highly valued.18 Peter Hujar emerged as a consistent outperformer relative to estimates.13 Irving Penn also saw strong results.13 Nan Goldin's work appeared frequently, sometimes leading sales where higher-estimated lots faltered.16 In terms of genre, the reported popularity of portraiture (especially celebrity), color photography, and nature/landscape themes provides qualitative insight into collector preferences.35

The Lower Price Point Market (Sub-$5,000)

This segment emerged as a clear area of strength and growth within the 2024 photography market. Analysis from ArtTactic, covering the period up to 2023 but indicative of trends continuing into 2024, showed a 36% year-on-year increase in sales value for photographs sold for under $5,000, with growth nearing 200% since 2019.12 ArtTactic's 2024 market report specifically included a focus analysis on this segment.1 This dynamism aligns with the broader art market trend of increased transaction volume 2 and growing collector confidence in purchasing affordable art online.12 Data showing that 80% of all artworks sold at auction globally in 2024 went for under $3,370, and nearly half a million lots sold for under $1,000, further underscores the significance of this lower-value tier where photography is abundantly represented.21

Spotlight on Women Photographers

The performance of women photographers was a notable aspect of the 2024 market. ArtTactic dedicated a specific focus to this segment in its annual report.1 Auction results demonstrated strong demand for key female figures when high-quality works came to market. Diane Arbus and Cindy Sherman secured places in the year's top 10 highest-priced lots.18 Works by Nan Goldin and Francesca Woodman also achieved significant results, sometimes exceeding expectations or leading sales.16 This aligns with broader trends showing an increased share for women artists in HNWI collections 37 and growing commercial interest on online platforms.34

The concurrent strength observed in both vintage masterworks 18 and the rapidly growing sub-$5,000 segment 1 suggests a photography market that is both maturing and broadening its appeal. It successfully caters to established collectors focused on historical rarity and connoisseurship, while simultaneously attracting a new generation of buyers entering the market through more accessible price points, often facilitated by online platforms. This dual appeal likely underpins much of the market's resilience.

The dynamism in the sub-$5,000 segment is intrinsically linked to the proliferation of online marketplaces and increased price transparency.35 This accessibility lowers the barrier to entry, fueling the rise in overall transaction volume seen across the art market.2 Photography, being well-suited to online presentation and frequently available at these price points, functions as a crucial gateway medium, potentially democratizing art collecting and bringing new participants into the fold.

While women photographers achieved significant results 16 and garnered increasing collector interest 34, their representation among the absolute highest prices realized at auction (Top 10 lots) remained limited compared to their male counterparts.18 This indicates that while substantial progress in recognition and demand is evident, achieving consistent parity at the very peak of secondary market valuations for photography is an ongoing process, suggesting further potential for market correction and value appreciation in this segment.

VII. Expert Perspectives and Market Sentiment

Qualitative insights from market reports and expert commentary provide valuable context for the quantitative data, revealing underlying sentiment and interpretations of the market's state in 2024.

Overall Market Sentiment

The prevailing sentiment regarding the 2024 art market was one of challenge and adjustment. It was widely characterized as a "buyer's market" 7, a period of necessary "recalibration" following the exuberant post-pandemic years 4, and an easing or slowdown in sales growth.20 Some commentators, like Christie's CEO Guillaume Cerutti, described it as a "year of two halves," suggesting some improvement or stabilization in the latter part of the year.11 The challenging macroeconomic environment was consistently cited as the primary driver of caution.2

Expert Commentary on Photography

Specific commentary on the photography market often highlighted its unique position and strengths within the broader art ecosystem. Analysts noted that photography benefited from the macro trend of collectors buying more art but at lower price levels.12 The medium's historical "stigma" as a lesser art form was seen as fading, aided by artists increasingly incorporating multiple media and strong institutional support through museum exhibitions.12 Photography's role as a successful entry-level market was emphasized, appealing due to its generally more accessible price points.12 The importance of price transparency, particularly in the online space, was also flagged as beneficial for the medium.35 Peter Fetterman's observation that photography now "parallels both the contemporary-art world and the Old Masters market" speaks to its broadening scope and historical depth.45 Specialist commentators, such as those at Collector Daily, provided granular analysis of auction results, noting Christie's dominance in securing top lots in 2024 but also characterizing the year as not particularly robust overall for high-value photography sales compared to previous peaks.18 The description of Paris Photo 2024 occurring during a "weird time for photography" hints at the complexities and transitions within the field.46

Collector Confidence and Outlook

Surveys and expert forecasts indicated a degree of cautious optimism returning towards the end of 2024 and looking ahead to 2025. A survey of HNWIs showed optimism about the art market's performance improving significantly from late 2023 to mid-2024.37 Expert predictions leaned towards market improvement in 2025 compared to 2024.7 Factors cited for this potential improvement included expected declines in interest rates, weakening inflation, and the passing of major election cycles, leading to a more stable and predictable economic and political environment.20 However, confidence indicators, such as the ArtTactic Confidence Indicator, remained relatively low through mid-2024, suggesting sentiment might lag behind improvements in financial markets.4

The consistent emphasis in expert commentary on photography's accessibility – encompassing its lower average price points, suitability for online sales, and the diminishing perception of it being a secondary art form 12 – strongly aligns with the quantitative data showing growth in the sub-$5k segment.1 This convergence suggests that the perceived democratization of photography is not merely a narrative but a core driver of its market dynamics and relative resilience in the challenging 2024 environment. This accessibility appears to be a defining characteristic and a significant source of strength.

While cautious optimism was emerging for the broader art market recovery in late 2024/early 2025 7, the specific attributes highlighted for photography suggest it might be particularly well-positioned to capitalize on any stabilization. Its established online infrastructure, appeal to emerging collectors, and strength at accessible price points 12 align well with the areas where market activity remained most robust during the downturn. This implies photography might not only participate in a general market recovery but could potentially lead aspects of it related to transaction volume and the acquisition of new buyers, leveraging its inherent accessibility.

VIII. Concluding Analysis and Outlook

The secondary market for fine art photography in 2024 demonstrated considerable resilience amidst a significant contraction in the broader global art market. While total auction sales value at the major houses saw a modest decline of 5.6% to $59.0 million, this performance was markedly better than the 27% drop experienced across other major fine art categories.1 The year was characterized by a distinct market bifurcation: pronounced caution and softness at the highest price levels in public auctions, contrasted with dynamism and growth in the more accessible sub-$5,000 segment and a notable shift towards private sales for high-value transactions.1

Key strengths supporting the photography market in 2024 included its relative value stability compared to more volatile segments, robust activity fueled by online platforms and increased price transparency, the fading of historical biases against the medium, and its growing appeal to a diverse range of collectors, including new entrants and those interested in women artists and emerging global talents.12 Photography's inherent accessibility, both in terms of price point and digital availability, proved advantageous in a value-conscious "buyer's market."

However, the market was not without challenges. The overall decline in value, though moderate, reflected the broader economic pressures. High-estimate lots frequently underperformed in public auctions, leading to significant buy-in rates in several sales.13 Furthermore, the peak prices achieved in 2024 were substantially lower than the record highs set in 2022, indicating a clear cooling at the very top end.18

Looking ahead to 2025, the secondary photography market appears reasonably well-positioned, particularly if the anticipated stabilization of the global economic and geopolitical climate materializes.7 The market's proven strengths – its strong online footprint, appeal to emerging collectors, diverse artist base, and robust activity at accessible price points – provide a solid foundation for continued engagement. Growth in the sub-$5,000 segment is likely to persist, driven by online accessibility and new buyer acquisition. The performance of the mid-range and high-end segments will depend more heavily on overall collector confidence returning and, crucially, the availability of exceptional, fresh-to-market consignments from both historical masters and leading contemporary figures. The trends towards greater diversity and the ongoing critical reappraisal of photographic artists suggest continued potential for discovery and value growth across various segments. Overall, while the market recalibrated in 2024, photography demonstrated structural advantages that could support its continued activity and relevance in the evolving art market landscape.

Works cited

1. Photography Auction Market 2024 | ArtTactic, accessed April 23, 2025, https://arttactic.com/reports/photography-auction-market-2024

2. 5 Key Takeaways from Art Basel and UBS's Report “The Art Market 2025” | Artsy, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.artsy.net/article/artsy-editorial-5-key-takeaways-art-basel-ubss-report-the-art-market-2025

3. Global instability and market contraction: A breakdown of the 2024 Global Art Market Report, accessed April 23, 2025, https://en.thevalue.com/articles/art-basel-ubs-arts-economics-decline-in-art-market-globally

4. Art Market Update Fall 2024: Key Trends and Analysis - Bank of America Private Bank, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.privatebank.bankofamerica.com/articles/art-market-fall-update.html

5. Art Market Reset: Riding the Waves of Change | Artnet News, accessed April 23, 2025, https://news.artnet.com/market/art-market-reset-riding-the-waves-of-change-2533656

6. The Art Market 2024 - A Year in Review - ArtTactic, accessed April 23, 2025, https://arttactic.com/reports/the-art-market-2024-a-year-in-review

7. Spring 2025 Art Market Update: Key Trends and Analysis, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.pbig.ml.com/articles/art-market-spring-update.html

8. Art Market Update Spring 2025: Trends to Watch and Analysis, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.privatebank.bankofamerica.com/articles/art-market-spring-update.html

9. How Much Art Sold Online in 2024? - Artnet News, accessed April 23, 2025, https://news.artnet.com/market/how-much-art-sold-online-in-2024-2634039

10. media.artnet.com, accessed April 23, 2025, https://media.artnet.com/image/upload/Artnet%20Intelligence%20Report%20Fall%202024/Artnet_IR_Mid-Year-Review_24.pdf

11. Christie's results are down 'just' 6% in 2024, 'despite challenging environment', accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.theartnewspaper.com/2024/12/17/christies-2024-results-down-6-percent-from-2023

12. How the photography trade is lifting as the medium's stigma fades - The Art Newspaper, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.theartnewspaper.com/2024/06/20/how-the-photography-trade-is-lifting-as-the-mediums-stigma-fades

13. Auction Results: Photographs, April 3, 2024 @Christie's (online) | Collector Daily, accessed April 23, 2025, https://collectordaily.com/auction-results-photographs-april-3-2024-christies-online/

14. Auction Results: Post-War to Present, October 1, 2024 @Christie's | Collector Daily, accessed April 23, 2025, https://collectordaily.com/auction-results-post-war-to-present-october-1-2024-christies/

15. Auction Results: Photographs, October 17, 2024 @Sotheby's (online) | Collector Daily, accessed April 23, 2025, https://collectordaily.com/auction-results-photographs-october-17-2024-sothebys-online/

16. Auction Results: Photographs, October 9, 2024 @Phillips - Collector Daily, accessed April 23, 2025, https://collectordaily.com/auction-results-photographs-october-9-2024-phillips/

17. Auction Results: Photographs, April 5, 2024 @Phillips - Collector Daily, accessed April 23, 2025, https://collectordaily.com/auction-results-photographs-april-5-2024-phillips/

18. Year in Review: Top 10 Highest Priced Photography Lots at Auction in 2024 | Collector Daily, accessed April 23, 2025, https://collectordaily.com/year-in-review-top-10-highest-priced-photography-lots-at-auction-in-2024/

19. The Art Basel & UBS Art Market Report 2023, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.ubs.com/global/en/our-firm/art/art-market-insights/download-market-report-2025/_jcr_content/root/contentarea/mainpar/toplevelgrid/col_1/actionbutton.0052659314.file/PS9jb250ZW50L2RhbS9hc3NldHMvY2MvYWJvdXQtdWJzL2NvbnRlbXBvcmFyeS1hcnQvcGRmL2FydC1iYXNlbC1hbmQtYXJ0LW1hcmtldC1yZXBvcnQtMjAyNS5wZGY=/art-basel-and-art-market-report-2025.pdf

20. The Art Market Remains Resilient in 2023, Despite a Slowdown in Sales | Art Basel, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.artbasel.com/stories/the-art-market-remains-resilient-in-2023--despite-a-slowdown-in-sales

21. Artmarket.com publishes 30th Art Market Report 2024: records, US in 1st place, EU and China tied for 2nd, France 2nd in volume, women artists keep rising - PR Newswire, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/artmarketcom-publishes-30th-art-market-report-2024-records-us-in-1st-place-eu-and-china-tied-for-2nd-france-2nd-in-volume-women-artists-keep-rising-302398461.html

22. The World's Leading Art Markets and Most Sought-After Art Forms - Stronddo Art, accessed April 23, 2025, https://stronddo.art/blogs/articles/the-worlds-leading-art-markets-and-most-sought-after-art-forms

23. How Fractional Art Investing Works - SoFi, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.sofi.com/learn/content/fractional-art/

24. Art Market Insights: Signals from the Recent Auctions in New York and Hong Kong, accessed April 23, 2025, https://observer.com/2024/10/2024-state-art-market-auctions-new-york-hong-kong/

25. Fall 2024 Art Market Update: Analysis and Trends to Watch - Merrill Lynch, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.ml.com/articles/art-market-fall-update.html

26. Data Dive: Auction Sales Are Down, but Which House Came Out on Top? - Artnet News, accessed April 23, 2025, https://news.artnet.com/market/data-dive-sales-by-auction-house-2542352

27. Auction Results: First Open | Post-War and Contemporary Art, December 18, 2024 @Christie's (online) | Collector Daily, accessed April 23, 2025, https://collectordaily.com/auction-results-first-open-post-war-and-contemporary-art-december-18-2024-christies-online/

28. Auction Results: Contemporary Curated, September 27, 2024 @Sotheby's | Collector Daily, accessed April 23, 2025, https://collectordaily.com/auction-results-contemporary-curated-september-27-2024-sothebys/

29. Photographs - Sotheby's, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.sothebys.com/en/buy/auction/2024/photographs-2?lotFilter=AllLots

30. Photographs - Sotheby's, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.sothebys.com/en/buy/auction/2024/photographs

31. Alfred Stieglitz Leads Phillips $3.55m 'Photographs' Auction in New York - HENI, accessed April 23, 2025, https://heni.com/news/article/alfred-stieglitz-leads-phillips-3-55m-photographs-auction-in-new-york-2024-10-09t14-00-00-04

32. Photographs, New York Friday, April 5, 2024 at EDT - Phillips Auction, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.phillips.com/auction/NY040124

33. Art Basel and UBS 2024 report: An in-depth analysis of the Art Market in 2023 - Kooness, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.kooness.com/posts/magazine/art-basel-and-ubs-2024-report-an-in-depth-analysis-of-the-art-market-in-2023

34. pages.artsy.net, accessed April 23, 2025, https://pages.artsy.net/rs/609-FDY-207/images/The%20Artsy%20Market%20Recap%202024.pdf

35. Exploring the Photography Market with Artsy: An Interview with Casey Lesser - All About Photo, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.all-about-photo.com/photo-articles/photo-article/1818/exploring-the-photography-market-with-artsy-an-interview-with-casey-lesser

36. Review 2024: Art Market, Art Trends and Tendencies - Arterritory, accessed April 23, 2025, https://arterritory.com/en/visual_arts/reviews/27375-review_2024_art_market_art_trends_and_tendencies/

37. The Art Basel and UBS Art Market Report 2025 | UBS Global, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.ubs.com/global/en/our-firm/art/art-market-insights.html

38. 5 Themes That Will Define the Art Market in 2025 | Artsy, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.artsy.net/article/artsy-editorial-5-themes-will-define-art-market-2025

39. The Artsy Market Recap 2024, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.artsy.net/article/artsy-editorial-artsy-market-recap-2024

40. The State of the Photography Market in 2024 - Artsy, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.artsy.net/article/artsy-editorial-state-photography-market-2024

41. The Art Basel and UBS Global Art Market Report 2024 by Arts Economics, accessed April 23, 2025, https://theartmarket.artbasel.com/download/The-Art-Basel-and-UBS-Art-Market-Report-2024.pdf

42. How Interest Rates Impact the Art Market | Artsy, accessed April 23, 2025, https://www.artsy.net/article/artsy-editorial-interest-rates-impact-art-market

43. State of The Photography Industry - April 2024 - Zenfolio, accessed April 23, 2025, https://zenfolio.com/sopi/2024-april/

44. Which Country's Art Market Came Out on Top in 2024? | Artnet News, accessed April 23, 2025, https://news.artnet.com/market/which-countrys-art-market-came-out-on-top-2629100

45. The Best-Seller Lists: Experts Analyze Trophy Lots Across 6 Categories | Artnet News, accessed April 23, 2025, https://news.artnet.com/market/the-best-seller-lists-experts-analyze-trophy-lots-across-6-categories-2624731

46. Lorraine O'Grady Artnet - Press | Mariane Ibrahim Gallery, accessed April 23, 2025, https://marianeibrahim.com/press/308-lorraine-o-grady-artnet/

REPORT DISCLAIMER
Information in this report is compiled from a number of sources; it may contain errors and information may not be complete. Readers must assume the responsibility of checking facts themselves.

Grem.World shall not be liable for any errors or inaccuracies in this report or for any actions taken in reliance on information or opinion contained in this report.
Report contents represent the opinion of Grem.World and state of affairs only as at the date the report is prepared and may quickly become out of date.
Information in this report is to be used for general research purposes only. It does not represent any form of investment or trading advice and should not
be used as such. Any statements referring to the desirability of holding, selling, or buying are general opinions and not recommendations to buy or sell any item or artist.
Further specialist advice, where necessary from authorized investment professionals, should be sought regarding the appropriateness of buying or selling
any works of art or implementing any of the strategies discussed or recommended in this report. Information in this report does not have regard to the
specific business or investment objectives, financial situation or other particular needs of any person.
Any buying and selling of works of art could result in a person losing money.
Copyright © 2025 Grem World LLC; This report and all intellectual property rights in or arising from it belong to Grem World LLC, and all rights in it are
reserved. No further copying or distribution of this report in whole or in part, by any means, is permitted.